Rusty Jimmies Seafood Market & Eatery Menu (2025 Update)

Welcome to Rusty Jimmies Seafood Market & Eatery, a hidden gem located at 300 Coastal Hwy, Fenwick Island, DE. This down-home eatery specializes in fresh, locally sourced seafood, capturing the essence of coastal dining. The menu features delightful options for every palate, including Little Crabbers dishes like Grilled Cheese and Fish & Chips, as well as the standout and must-try Crab and Fresh Fish.

Guests rave about the quality and flavor, noting the attention to detail, from perfectly cooked crabs to tender crab cakes. The friendly owner, Chris, not only serves up delicious plates but also shares stories of local crabbing, creating an inviting atmosphere. Pair your meal with refreshing drinks like lemonade or bottled water, and enjoy a unique dining experience that resonates with the heart of Fenwick Island.